Homeschool and School Choice Plan

Private family planning page · updated 2026-11-21

The plan: homeschool through elementary with our church co-op once a week, then classical Christian school from middle school. His week: Taekwondo 2×/week (late afternoon), our church co-op once a week, Sunday school. Birthday: June. That makes him kindergarten-age in fall 2027 (Virginia).

Why we're choosing this route

Revise this until you both can say it from memory. On a hard day, this is the sentence that keeps you on course or tells you honestly that it's time to change course.

Our reasons

1. It fits how he's made. Sensitive kids respond more strongly to their environment, for better and for worse (see the Environment section below). In elementary school his environment shapes him most, and at home we can make it the best one available: calm, predictable, warm, with correction given privately. We're not avoiding the world; we're choosing the setting where he can grow fastest.

2. Discipleship is our job first. Scripture puts the main responsibility for a child's instruction on his parents (Deut 6:6–7; Eph 6:4). The 1689 Confession expects daily worship in the home (22.6). Homeschooling means the catechism, Scripture memory, and family worship aren't squeezed into evenings after someone else's school day. They're built into the school day itself. Add your own verses and convictions here:

3. He grows up inside our church. The church co-op, Sunday school, and church life mean his peers and adults outside the family mostly come from our church. He sees the same faces across settings, which is good for his sense of security and good for discipleship.

4. It fits the classical goal instead of competing with it. Classical education begins with the grammar stage (roughly K–5): memory work, phonics, stories, chants, and catechism. That stage works well at home, in short lessons with one-on-one attention. The logic stage (middle school) is built on discussion, debate, and argument with peers, which is where a classroom becomes worth more. Our plan puts each stage where it works best.

5. It keeps our options open. At home we can adjust pace subject by subject, settle his grade placement later, and respond to anything we learn (an OT evaluation, a new sibling, a job change) without fighting a school's calendar or policies.

6. He's not isolated; he's exposed on purpose. Taekwondo twice a week, co-op weekly, and Sunday school give him regular practice with other adults, groups, rules, and performing. These activities are a planned part of his schooling, not extras.

7. Cost (secondary, but real). Full-time classical tuition through elementary would cost a great deal (Ad Fontes listed about $14,800/yr several years ago). Homeschooling those years frees money to put toward the school years that need it most.

Why not the alternatives (for now)

How we'll know it's working

What would make us revisit the plan

Answering friends and family

Ground rules for these conversations

Family members who don't understand it

What they might say

"Won't he be weird or unsocialized?" "Are you even qualified to teach?" "Will he get into college?" "Isn't this a lot for you two?"

Short answer

"He'll be with other kids and adults four times a week: Taekwondo twice, co-op, and Sunday school. At home he gets one-on-one teaching, and he moves into a classical school by middle school."

If they want more

  • Socialization: research reviews have generally found homeschooled kids do as well as or better than schooled kids on social skills (Richard Medlin, Peabody Journal of Education, 2013). More importantly, his social time is with mixed ages and with adults, not only a room of 20 five-year-olds.
  • Qualifications: Virginia allows parents to homeschool and requires yearly evidence of progress. Teaching one child at his level is very different from managing a classroom.
  • College: he'll finish in a classical Christian school with a transcript, grades, and test scores like any other student.
  • The load on us: fair. That's why burnout is one of our "tripwires" and we review the plan every summer.
  • Invite them in: grandparents and relatives can be part of it, e.g., hearing his recitations over video, read-alouds, nature walks.

Theologically liberal Christian friends

What they might say

"Isn't this sheltering him? Faith should be open to questions." "Isn't that a fundamentalist thing?" "He needs to meet people who think differently."

Short answer

"We actually want him to ask big questions. Classical education has him reading Plato, Augustine, and the great debates of history in their own words. We're teaching him how to think and argue well before he's asked to judge everything."

If they want more

  • Classical Christian education is the opposite of anti-intellectual: primary sources, formal logic, rhetoric, and taking opposing arguments seriously.
  • Formation comes before critique. Children learn the content of a tradition first (the grammar stage), then learn to question and test it (logic), then to articulate and defend it (rhetoric). That's ordinary teaching, not fear.
  • Christians have taught their children the faith on purpose for as long as there has been a church. Catechesis isn't a new or fringe idea.
  • He will meet people who think differently: at Taekwondo, in our neighborhood, through relatives, and through the books he reads.
  • Add our own convictions here, in our words:

Friends who don't understand classical education

What they might say

"What even is classical?" "Latin is a dead language." "Isn't it elitist or old-fashioned?" "Why not just use regular school?"

Short answer

"It teaches in three stages: first the facts and language of a subject, then how to reason about it, then how to express it well. It's how much of the West was educated for centuries."

If they want more

  • The three stages (the trivium): grammar (K–5: memory, phonics, stories), logic (6–8: argument, asking why), rhetoric (9–12: writing and speaking persuasively). They match how children naturally develop.
  • Latin: builds English vocabulary (a large share of English words come from Latin), teaches grammar systematically, and trains careful thinking. It's a tool, not a museum piece.
  • Not elitist: homeschooling the early years is the least expensive way to get there. Many classical schools exist specifically to make it affordable.
  • A good short read to pass along: Dorothy Sayers, "The Lost Tools of Learning" (1947), the essay that sparked the modern classical revival.

Friends who say, "Public school is free"

What they might say

"Why pay for something you can get for free?" "Public schools around here are good." "Isn't that a waste of money?"

Short answer

"Fairfax schools are good. This isn't about quality. It's about what fits this child, and homeschooling the early years actually costs us very little."

If they want more

  • Cost: homeschooling elementary costs far less than private school (curriculum and co-op fees, versus private tuition that runs well over $10,000 a year). We're spending carefully, not lavishly.
  • "Free" still has costs for him: full days, classes of 20+, more noise and testing pressure. For a highly sensitive five-year-old, those costs are real.
  • We're still public-school supporters as taxpayers. We pay for them gladly and want them to be excellent for the families who use them.

Friends who trust public institutions to do good

What they might say

"Public schools are a common good; leaving them weakens them." "The government has resources and specialists you don't." "Isn't this a political statement?"

Short answer

"We agree public schools do a lot of good, and we're glad to support them as taxpayers. This isn't a political statement. It's a parenting decision about one particular child."

If they want more

  • Where we agree: public institutions serve many families well, especially those without other options. We don't want them to fail.
  • Who decides: in both law and conviction, parents are a child's primary educators. The Supreme Court said so in Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925): "The child is not the mere creature of the State." Virginia's homeschool law reflects the same principle.
  • Spheres of responsibility: family, church, and state each have their own proper authority (Abraham Kuyper's "sphere sovereignty"). The state serves families. It doesn't replace them.
  • Specialists: we can still use public resources. Fairfax County must evaluate any child for free through "Child Find," including homeschooled children.

Friends who say kids should be salt and light

What they might say

"Christian kids should be in public school to be a witness." "Aren't you pulling him out of the mission field?" "Jesus didn't call us to hide."

Short answer

"We want him to be salt and light. That's why we're grounding him first. Right now he's five; he's being discipled, not deployed. And our family is still out in the world every week."

If they want more

  • Who Jesus was speaking to: "You are the salt of the earth… the light of the world" (Matt 5:13–16) was spoken to disciples. Children need to be discipled before they're sent.
  • We don't send recruits into battle untrained. A five-year-old can't yet tell the difference between what his teacher says and what Scripture says, or stand alone against a room of peers.
  • He's still out in the world: Taekwondo and our neighborhood are full of kids and families from every background. That's where his witness starts, with us beside him.
  • Mom and Dad are missionaries too: our work, friendships, and neighbors are our mission field. Our family's witness isn't on hold.
  • The goal is a long, durable witness: a young man who knows what he believes and why, rather than a child who gave up his faith by middle school.

Key decisions and options to consider

Option A: Enter Ad Fontes before middle school

Ad Fontes is full-time and close to home (Centreville). Joining a class at 11 or 12, after they've been together for years, is the hardest version of the switch.

Option B: Use Potomac Classical as a bridge

PCC is hybrid by design (on campus Tue/Wed/Fri, home Mon/Thu), runs K–10, and is in Alexandria.

Option C: Stay home longer

If he's thriving at home and at co-op, there's no rule that he must switch at a set grade. Staying home through 6th and entering at 7th is also an option. Weigh this against the "joining an established class" risk.

Option D: Decide grade placement later

Because he's taught at his own level at home, his grade is just a label until he enters a school. With a June birthday and Ad Fontes' Aug 31 cutoff, he'd be one of the youngest if kept "on time." Placing him a year back makes him one of the oldest, which may help a sensitive boy joining a new class at 11–12. This decision can wait until about 3rd grade.

Delaying kindergarten

Families usually wait a year when a child has a summer birthday and also seems young for his age: big separation anxiety, short attention, trouble with transitions, or fine-motor skills (pencil, scissors) that aren't ready. Waiting buys time for those things to mature. The research shows little lasting academic benefit. What helps is emotional readiness.

For us, the real decision comes later. At home he can be taught at whatever level he's at, so "kindergarten" is just a label for now. It only matters when he enters a school. Ad Fontes' cutoff is August 31, so a June birthday puts him on time but among the youngest in his class. Because he's sensitive, will be joining a new group at 11 or 12, and boys mature physically at different rates, being one of the oldest could help him then. → Settle his grade around 3rd–4th grade, once his maturity is clearer.

Environment: why it matters so much for him

Sensitive kids respond more strongly to their surroundings in both directions. A rough setting hits them harder than other kids, and a good one helps them more. ("Differential susceptibility": Belsky, Pluess, Boyce's "orchid" children.)

For the next several years, our home is his school, so the climate of our home is the biggest factor in how school goes. The co-op, Taekwondo and Sunday school are where he practices handling the wider world in small doses.

The risks, and what to do about each

1. Avoidance can grow

Avoiding something hard brings relief, and the relief makes him want to avoid it again. Homeschool makes it easy to steer around things without noticing.

  • Stretch, don't push. Talk through new situations ahead of time and arrive early.
  • Take small steps. Stay in the room the first time, wait outside the next.
  • Talk it over afterward. "What was hard? What did you do?"
  • Taekwondo is our best tool here: an adult in charge who isn't a parent, performing in front of others, and belt tests that are low-stakes pressure.

2. Perfectionism

One-on-one teaching means every mistake gets noticed.

  • Let him see us make mistakes and fix them calmly.
  • End lessons on time, even if the work isn't finished.
  • Praise effort ("you kept trying"), not being smart.
  • Keep correction about the work, not about him: "Let's fix this word," then move on warmly.

3. He takes on the teaching parent's stress

Sensitive kids read moods closely, so a stressed, worn-out parent at the table usually means a stressed, worn-out child. The teaching parent's rest belongs in the plan.

  • The other parent takes one regular time slot, like a Saturday read-aloud or nature walk.

4. Giving in too much

Overwhelmed and reluctant look the same in the moment.

  • Overwhelmed: the problem goes away once he's calm, so he needs a break.
  • Reluctant: it comes back every time the task does, so hold the line kindly.
  • If sensory problems get in the way of ordinary tasks, get an occupational therapy (OT) evaluation early. Ad Fontes says it can offer only limited support for accommodations, so we'd want to know well before applying.

5. Joining a class that has been together for years

At 11 or 12 he'd be walking into a group that already knows each other.

  • Help him make friends with kids at the target school.
  • Look for their camps or days when visitors can sit in on class.
  • Think about entering a year early (see the comparison below).

6. Overscheduling, especially in the evening

Taekwondo falls at the most tired part of a 4-year-old's day.

  • Prefer the earlier class time if the weekly schedule allows. The later class pushes dinner and bedtime late.
  • Give him a snack before class. Hunger plus fatigue is when meltdowns happen.
  • Avoid Taekwondo on co-op day if we can.
  • Keep at least two weekdays fully at home.

What to look for (home, co-op, dojang, and a future school)

The same six checks apply everywhere he spends time. Use them to observe the settings he's in now (home, co-op, Taekwondo, Sunday school) and to judge schools on visits later.

1. Adults: calm and warm, and they correct quietly and in private

The adult in charge matters more than the program or curriculum. A sensitive child feels a harsh tone or public correction strongly and remembers it for a long time.

Good signs

  • They speak at normal volume, even when redirecting a child.
  • Correction is short, private, and specific: they kneel down and say "Feet on the floor, please." No lecture in front of the group.
  • They notice the quiet kids, not just the loud ones.
  • After a correction the relationship is fine: a smile or a "thank you" follows.

Warning signs

  • Yelling, sarcasm, or embarrassing a child in front of others ("Everyone's waiting on you").
  • Comparing children ("Why can't you sit like Sam?").
  • Punishing the whole group for one child.
  • Being impatient with slow starters.

Ask

  • "How do you correct a child who isn't following directions?"
  • "What does a typical redirect sound like?"

Where it applies

  • Home: this is the standard for us too, especially at the lesson table.
  • Dojang: martial arts instructors range from drill-sergeant to coach. Watch how the instructor corrects a 4–5-year-old who's goofing off.
  • Co-op and Sunday school: volunteer teachers vary from week to week. Notice which ones he responds to and mention it to the leaders.

2. Predictability: a routine he can count on, warnings before transitions

Sudden changes are one of the hardest things for him. Knowing what comes next lowers his stress before anything even happens.

Good signs

  • The day or class follows the same order every time: opening, lesson, activity, closing.
  • A visual schedule, or the teacher says what's coming ("After snack we'll go outside").
  • Transition warnings: "Five more minutes," then "one more minute," a song, or a bell.
  • Changes (a substitute, a field trip, a fire drill) are announced ahead of time when possible.

Warning signs

  • A different structure every week, or one that depends on the teacher's mood.
  • Activities ending abruptly with "Stop, clean up, line up!"
  • Lots of surprises presented as fun (sudden games, unannounced guests).

Ask

  • "What does a normal day or class look like, start to finish?"
  • "How do you handle transitions?"
  • "How do you tell kids about changes to the routine?"

Where it applies

  • Home: keep the same lesson order each day, and use a simple picture chart of the morning if it helps. Give the five-minute warning before Taekwondo too.
  • Dojang: most classes follow a set pattern (bow in, warm-up, drills, bow out), which is a strength. Belt tests and tournaments break the pattern, so prepare him for those in advance.

3. Sensory load: how many kids, how loud, somewhere quiet to reset

Noise, crowds, bright lights, and physical closeness add up over a day. A setting can be kind and well run and still be too much for him.

Good signs

  • Small groups, or a big group broken into smaller ones.
  • A moderate noise level, with soft surfaces, rugs, and no echo.
  • A quiet corner, reading nook, or hallway bench where a child is allowed to step away. It shouldn't be a punishment spot.
  • Outdoor time and movement breaks built in.
  • No harsh fluorescent lights, blaring music, or strong smells if possible.

Warning signs

  • A gym or fellowship hall packed with kids and echoing.
  • Constant background music or screens.
  • Nowhere to retreat without leaving the room.
  • Long stretches of sitting still with no movement.

Ask

  • "How many kids per adult?"
  • "Where can a child go if they need a break? Who decides when they need one?"

Where it applies

  • Co-op: church buildings often have loud fellowship halls. Find out where his class meets and whether there's a quieter room nearby.
  • Dojang: kiais (shouts) and group yelling are part of the art. Watch whether he flinches or warms up to it. It could be good practice in small doses.
  • Future school: visit during lunch, recess, or a class change, not just a quiet classroom.

4. Big feelings: ask, "What do you do when a child cries or shuts down?"

He will have big reactions in public at some point. What matters is how the adults respond.

Good signs

  • A calm, specific answer: "I get down to their level, name the feeling, give them a minute, offer the quiet spot, then help them rejoin."
  • Feelings are treated as normal, while behavior still has limits ("It's okay to be upset. It's not okay to hit").
  • Parents are told afterward, without shaming the child.
  • The adult talks with the child, not about the child in front of others.

Warning signs

  • A vague or dismissive answer ("We don't really have that problem," "Kids just need to toughen up").
  • Ignoring a crying child, or making them sit out with no help.
  • Rewarding "being brave" in a way that makes him hide feelings instead of handling them.
  • A habit of calling parents to pick up the child as the main strategy.

Ask

  • The question itself, plus: "Can you tell me about the last time it happened?" A real example tells you more than a policy.

Where it applies

  • Home: this is ours to model. Stay calm, name the feeling ("You're frustrated because the letter won't come out right"), help him reset, and then return to the task.
  • Dojang: some instructors push "no crying on the mat." Learn this one's approach before a hard belt test.

5. Performance: how much public reciting is required, and whether he can build up to it

Classical education uses a lot of recitation, presentations, and memory work in front of others. Taekwondo has forms, sparring, and belt tests. This can be a real strength for him if it builds up gradually, or a source of dread if it's thrown at him.

Good signs

  • Kids recite as a group first, then in pairs, then alone.
  • A child can say "not today" and try again next week without penalty.
  • Mistakes during a recitation are handled lightly ("Good, try that line again").
  • Performances are short, and the audience is familiar.

Warning signs

  • Every child stands alone in front of the class from day one.
  • Being ranked or compared publicly (leaderboards, "who knows it best?").
  • Grades or belts depend on a single high-pressure moment with no second chance.

Ask

  • "How often do students present or recite alone?"
  • "What happens if a child freezes?"

Where it applies

  • Home: practice recitation to a stuffed animal, then a parent, then a grandparent on a video call. Small audiences first.
  • Dojang: belt tests are the main performance event. Ask whether he can retest if he freezes, and do a practice run at home.
  • Ad Fontes / PCC: both will include recitation and public speaking. On a visit, ask how they bring a quiet child along.

6. Afterward: judge by how he is at home that evening, not how he seemed while there

Sensitive kids often hold it together in public and fall apart at home. A teacher may honestly say "He was great!" while he melts down at dinner. The evening shows what the day cost him.

What to watch the evening after

  • Meltdowns: how big, and how long it takes him to recover.
  • Sleep: how hard it is to fall asleep, and any night waking.
  • Appetite: how much and how picky he is at dinner.
  • Withdrawal: wanting to be alone, or clinging to a parent.
  • What he talks about: happy stories, worried questions, or nothing at all.
  • The next morning: whether he's eager or reluctant to go back.

How to use it

  • Keep a quick log for a few weeks. One line per day is enough ("Co-op, then TKD: big meltdown at bath. Co-op only: fine").
  • Look for patterns, not single bad nights. Every kid has off days.
  • If one setting keeps producing bad evenings, change one thing at a time: move the TKD day, shorten the stay, or add a snack and quiet time right after.
  • A good sign over time: evenings after the same activity get easier. That's him adapting, which is the goal.

Quick reference by setting

Check Home church co-op Dojang Future school visit
Adults Our tone at the lesson table Which volunteers he responds to How the instructor corrects young kids Watch a teacher redirect a child
Predictability Same lesson order daily Same room and order weekly? Bow-in / bow-out structure Ask for a typical day
Sensory load Quiet space, outdoor time Fellowship-hall noise Kiais and group shouting Visit at lunch or recess
Big feelings We model it Ask the leaders "No crying on the mat"? Ask for a real recent example
Performance Practice with small audiences Group recitation? Belt tests, retests How they bring a quiet child along
Afterward — That evening That evening Trial day, then that evening

Comparing our options

Homeschool + church co-op (now) Potomac Classical Conservatory Ad Fontes Academy
Model Home, with co-op 1×/week Hybrid: on campus Tue/Wed/Fri, home the other days Full-time classical Christian, ACCS-accredited
Grades — K–10 K–12
Location Home / church Alexandria, likely 30–45 min each way in traffic Centreville, close to Fairfax
Fit for a sensitive child Most control over pace and sensory load Built-in home days for recovery, hybrid by design Most structure and a stable peer group
Watch for Avoidance, perfectionism, burnout for the teaching parent Commute, and Wed/Fri on-campus days running into Taekwondo Limited accommodations; K classes up to 20
Entry — Hybrid makes a mid-elementary start easier Application, teacher referral, assessment ($295 fee as of 2026)

→ For when and how to move into each school (entering Ad Fontes early, PCC as a bridge, staying home longer, grade placement), see Key decisions and options to consider near the top.

Virginia homeschool law (confirm on HEAV)

Open questions and next steps

Tap to check items off. Checkmarks are saved on this device only.

Sources